Gel Manicures vs Shellac Manicures: 11 Key Differences
Gel manicures and Shellac manicures are the most requested long‑lasting nail treatments in Australian salons. Both deliver a glossy, chip‑resistant finish, but they differ in formula, application time, durability, removal, feel on the nail, and best‑fit use cases.
- Formula: Gel = pure gel polish; Shellac = hybrid of gel + traditional lacquer (thinner film).
- Application time: Gel ≈ 45–60 min; Shellac ≈ 30–45 min (thinner layers cure faster).
- Durability: Gel ≈ 2–3 weeks; Shellac ≈ 10–14 days (with good aftercare).
- Removal: Gel = 10–15 min soak + possible light filing; Shellac = 5–10 min soak, minimal filing.
- Best for: Gel = maximum wear + nail art; Shellac = natural, lightweight look + faster salon visits.
What is a Gel Manicure?
A gel manicure is a professional nail service using a gel‑based polish composed of acrylic monomers and oligomers. Each coat (base, colour, top) cures under UV or LED lamps, hardening via photopolymerisation into a structured, chip‑resistant film that typically lasts two to three weeks.
- Longest‑lasting high‑gloss finish in the salon category.
- Excellent canvas for nail art and complex effects.
- Slightly thicker, more rigid reinforcement of the natural nail.
What is a Shellac Manicure?
A Shellac manicure is a hybrid nail coating that blends the application ease of traditional polish with gel‑like durability. Applied in thin layers and cured under UV/LED light, Shellac forms a lightweight, flexible, high‑gloss film that usually wears 10–14 days.
- Natural, polish‑like look and feel.
- Faster soak‑off with less acetone exposure.
- Quicker appointment time than most gel services.
Gel vs Shellac: Detailed Comparison
Diving deeper into the nuances reveals how these treatments align with personal priorities, from endurance in demanding routines to gentleness for delicate nail beds.
User experiences underscore gel's robust appeal for longevity enthusiasts, while Shellac garners affection for its forgiving, natural essence—ultimately, the choice hinges on balancing aesthetic desires with practical realities.
| Feature | Gel Manicure | Shellac Manicure |
|---|---|---|
| Formula | Pure gel polish (acrylic monomers/oligomers); higher viscosity | Hybrid of gel + traditional lacquer; thinner, lighter film |
| Application time | 45–60 min (multiple coats + curing) | 30–45 min (thinner layers cure faster) |
| Curing method | UV or LED lamp; photopolymerisation creates a hard, structured film | UV or LED lamp; thin coats polymerise into a flexible coating |
| Finish & appearance | Very glossy, structured, slightly thicker; ideal for bold nail art | Very glossy, natural‑looking, thinner; polish‑like aesthetic |
| Durability | ~2–3 weeks with proper prep/aftercare | ~10–14 days (may reach ~3 weeks with excellent aftercare) |
| Strength vs flex | Rigid, adds reinforcement | Flexible, moves with the natural nail |
| Removal process | 10–15 min acetone soak; may need light file to break top coat | 5–10 min acetone soak; minimal to no filing |
| Impact on nail health | Safe when professionally removed; peeling/over‑filing can cause dryness | Gentler soak‑off lowers acetone exposure; reduced dehydration risk |
| Colour range | Very broad across many gel systems; advanced finishes supported | Curated palette tied to Shellac system; fewer specialty effects |
| Maintenance cycle | Professional removal/reapply every 2–3 weeks | Faster removal and reapply; suits frequent refresh |
| Typical cost (Sydney) | AUD ~$40–$70 depending on design/salon | AUD ~$45–$80 depending on service/salon |
Which Lasts Longer: Gel or Shellac?
Gel generally lasts up to three weeks (21 days) without chipping; Shellac typically wears 10–14 days. Prep quality, nail condition, and glove use for chores influence both.
How Are Gel Manicures and Shellac Manicures Applied?
Applying a Gel manicure
- Nail prep: cleanse, shape, cuticle care, gentle buff
- Base coat → cure
- Two to three colour coats → cure after each
- Top coat → cure, cleanse dispersion layer
Applying a Shellac manicure
- Identical prep
- Base coat → cure
- One to two thin colour coats → cure after each
- Top coat → cure, quick alcohol swipe for gloss
How Are Gel Manicures and Shellac Manicures Removed?
- Gel: Wrap/soak in acetone 10–15 min; light surface break may be needed. Avoid peeling/scraping.
- Shellac: Wrap/soak 5–10 min; thin film lifts with minimal mechanical action.
Apply SPF 30+ to hands or use UV‑protective gloves before curing to minimise UVA exposure.
Cost in Sydney for Gel Manicures and Shellac Manicures
Prices vary by salon and finish. Recent menus show Shellac manicures around ~AUD $45–$60 and gel finishes ~AUD $40–$70+, with add‑ons (French, art, chrome) increasing totals.
Which Should You Choose? Gel Manicures or Shellac Manicures?
Gel = maximum longevity and art. Shellac = natural, lightweight finish with faster removal and shorter appointments.
Book a Long‑Wear Manicure Service in Sydney
Enjoy expert nail shaping, cuticle care and a high‑gloss finish—choose Gel or Shellac with professional prep, safe curing and gentle removal.
Book Your AppointmentMaintenance Tips for Gel Manicures and Shellac Manicures
- Daily cuticle oil for hydration and flexibility
- Gloves for cleaning/chemicals
- Never peel; book professional removal
- SPF 30+ or UV‑shield gloves before lamp curing
FAQs about Gel Manicures and Shellac Manicures
Before booking, clients often ask these practical, search‑driven questions.
Which lasts longer: gel or Shellac?
Gel typically lasts up to three weeks; Shellac commonly wears 10–14 days.
Is Shellac healthier than gel?
Shellac’s thinner film and faster soak‑off reduce acetone exposure; both are safe with professional removal.
Are gel and Shellac safe for nails?
Yes, when applied/removed by trained technicians. Use SPF 30+ or UV gloves for lamp curing.
What are the long‑term effects on nail health?
Improper removal (peeling, over‑filing) can thin or dehydrate nails; breaks and moisturising help recovery.
How does the application process differ?
Gel tends to use thicker coats and more layering; Shellac uses thinner coats for a faster service.
What are the removal differences?
Gel: 10–15 min soak and possible surface break. Shellac: 5–10 min soak, minimal filing.
Which is better for sensitive or brittle nails?
Shellac’s flexible, thin coating and gentle soak‑off suit delicate nails; gel’s rigid structure needs careful removal.
How do costs compare in Australia?
Shellac manicures often advertise from ~$45–$60; gel finishes vary ~$40–$70+, rising with art/finish.
Can gel or Shellac be done at home?
Kits exist, but salon‑grade lamps and professional removal improve safety and results.
How to choose based on lifestyle?
High‑impact or frequent hand‑washing → Gel. Preference for natural look and faster visits → Shellac.
